Every position that is not intuitively true must be supported by an argument.
An argument
comprises two parts: reason and conclusion.
The reason
is the set of statements that claim to imply the position (or conclusion). Each such statement is called a premiss.
The conclusion
is the statement that the reason claims to support.
Every argument
must pass two tests.
The first
test is validity: the reason must imply only the conclusion.
The second
test is truth: every premiss must be true.
We must accept
any argument that passes both tests.
Premisses
that are not intuitively true must be separately supported by a branch argument.
An argument
can be rebutted on only two counts: invalidity (the reason does not imply only the conclusion) and non-truth (a premiss false
or uncertain).
An argument
for an opposing conclusion (or a counterargument) is not a rebuttal.
A complex
argument (one with trunk and branches) is more easily attacked than a simple argument (trunk only).
A position
is better supported by many trunks than by many branches.
To make a
case: One accepted argument.
To break
a case: Rebut all arguments.